SAN DIEGO – The San Diego City Council took the first step Tuesday in capping short-term rentals at 1% of the city’s housing supply and prioritizing “good actors” in a lottery to determine who gets to offer homes for whole-home vacation rentals.
The council voted 8-1 to approve the first reading of the ordinance, which City Council President Jennifer Campbell called a compromise between property owners and corporate rental services such as VRBO and Airbnb.
Around 16,000 short-term rentals are currently in the city. With a shortage of affordable housing, some people argue reducing short-term rentals would free up units for locals. Others have been pushing for changes because they’re tired of Airbnb parties going on next door.
The city estimates there will be a little over 5,000 licenses handed out when the ordinance goes into effect in 2022. Final approval requires a second vote at a future council meeting.
The ordinance will return to council in October for updates on the lottery and prioritization related to licensing with details of the new restrictions ironed out over the coming months.
“We’ve considered many perspectives and believe we have crafted what is best for our city,” Campbell said.
Campbell thanked “everyone who was a part of putting together this ordinance and who has fought so hard to implement common sense ideas to our city.”
“This ordinance shows San Diegans that our city government can do what we’re elected to do — to solve our most confounding problems with workable solutions,” Campbell said.
The ordinance places short-term rentals into four categories: part-time rentals rented 20 days a year; home-sharing rentals; whole-home rentals; and whole-home rentals in Mission Beach. The latter two are the subject of the ordinance’s most strict restrictions.
Highlights of the ordinance include:
- Capping whole-home short-term rentals at 1% of the city’s housing stock per the San Diego Planning Commission, which presently equates to 5,400;
- Reducing whole-home short-term rentals based on the city auditor’s estimation that more than 14,700 short-term rentals exist, including 1,667 in Mission Beach;
- Not limiting home-sharing short-term rentals;
- Allowing part-time short-term rental operators to obtain a license at lower annual fees to accommodate high visitor events;
- Yearly assessment of the program to determine if it is equitable and effective;
- Requiring a local contact be able to respond to disturbances at the property in one hour or less;
- Allowing short-term rental owners a maximum of one license, per person; and
- Creating a detailed Good Neighbor Policy along with strict enforcement guidelines, a fine structure for violations, and a license revocation standard.
More than 130 people called into the council meeting, many to express relief the city was tackling the long-simmering issue, but others to express dismay at the “lottery” system which would assign short-term rental licenses to home owners.
One Mission Bay resident described the lottery as inherently unfair because she had used her property in a “strict” manner and didn’t allow large parties or gatherings. She said people who have abided by city laws in renting homes should receive priority in receiving a license under the new ordinance.
Councilman Raul Campillo agreed. He successfully amended the ordinance to prioritize “good actors” when licensing begins later this year.
The sole no vote was Councilman Joe LaCava, who proposed four amendments which would have been much stricter than the version which passed. He was concerned with equity in the ordinance and how to hold rental platforms accountable.
Councilwomen Monica Montgomery Steppe and Marni von Wilpert and Councilman Sean Elo Rivera shared LaCava’s concerns but voted to pass the ordinance with the intention to refine it later.
The reduced number of short-term rentals will reduce the city’s Transient Occupancy Tax — essentially a hotel tax — by between $4.4 million and $7.3 million annually, according to a report from the Office of the Independent Budget Analyst.
Mayor Todd Gloria applauded the council on the vote and said he would do what he could to ensure it was enforced.
“Should the council take the final step in adopting these regulations, my administration will ensure that they are fully and faithfully implemented and enforced. I am committed to revisiting these regulations and assessing their efficacy after one year,” he said.
Organizations such as Save San Diego Neighborhoods are far from pleased with the plan, which it called a “multibillion dollar theft of San Diego housing, by legalizing short-term vacation rentals in residential neighborhoods citywide.”
That organization claims the ordinance is illegal on the basis of not being consistent with the city’s general plan and coastal program. Save San Diego Neighborhoods threatened litigation if the city council passed the ordinance.
Campbell said her ordinance will increase the housing supply.
“San Diegans will have more homes to buy or rent, neighborhoods will see a massive reduction in STRs in their communities with real enforcement to weed out bad actors,” Campbell said.
“This truly represents what San Diegans want to see: an end to the ‘wild west’ STR environment that has negatively impacted so many.”