Closing arguments made in fatal road-rage stabbing trial

Data pix.

CHULA VISTA, Calif. -- A man fatally stabbed another motorist seven times on a South Bay roadway following a road rage dispute, a prosecutor said Tuesday, while a defense attorney alleged his client defended himself when attacked.

Rickey Vernon Smith, 60, is charged with the murder of 36-year-old Horace Williams Jr., a father of five who was stabbed last Nov. 27 following a run-in with the defendant that ended near the Chula Vista Golf Course.

The behind-the-wheel altercation involved Williams allegedly throwing a soda cup at Smith's pickup truck and Smith ramming Williams' minivan during a long back-and-forth dispute between the two drivers.

Deputy District Attorney Makenzie Harvey alleged that after cutting Williams off for the final time, Smith got out of his truck, walked up to Williams' driver's side window and punched him.

He then walked away, pulled out a knife from a holster strapped to his hip, walked back to the minivan and stabbed Williams, with the fatal blow puncturing Williams' heart, the prosecutor alleged. Williams also sustained stab wounds to his arms and legs.

Witnesses saw Williams get out of his van and collapse in the roadway, bleeding heavily. Paramedics took him to Scripps Mercy Hospital in San Diego, where he was pronounced dead.

Jurors heard the 911 call Smith made shortly after the stabbing, in which he said Williams cut him off and threw a drink at his truck. Smith told the dispatcher that he followed Williams to find out why he did that, then later admitted to punching and stabbing Williams. Smith said in the call that Williams punched him and that he stabbed Williams before he could be punched any further.

Smith also stated that Williams threw a drink at his vehicle "for no reason at all."

"I was just minding my own business," he told the dispatcher. "It wouldn't have happened if he wouldn't have been bothering me."

Defense attorney Brian Watkins told jurors in his closing argument that Williams was the aggressor and that he punched Smith twice in the face when Smith approached Williams' window. Only after Williams began reaching for something near the center console did Smith produce his knife "as a last resort," Watkins said.

Harvey countered that there was no physical evidence of injuries to indicate Smith had been punched.

She also emphasized that Smith never made mention of Williams reaching for a weapon in his phone call with the 911 dispatcher. Further investigation showed that Williams was unarmed, though Watkins said Smith's belief that Williams could have been reaching for a weapon was enough to qualify for lawful self-defense.

Watkins alleged that "Horace Williams created this situation" by cutting his client off on the road, then throwing the drink at his truck, which "goes well above and beyond your normal road rage."

Watkins said that after punching his client twice, Smith produced the knife to defend himself. The attorney said that as Smith was holding the blade toward his attacker, Williams tried to get out of his van to fight Smith and ran into the blade at least twice at chest level.

Harvey told the jury there was "no way" the stabbing could have occurred the way the defense presented, citing the heavy material of Williams' clothing and how deep the stab wounds penetrated, which she alleged could only happen through forceful thrusts made by the defendant.

Smith is in custody on $2 million bail.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.