Council votes to require mayor to sign tourism agreement

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SAN DIEGO — The San Diego City Council Tuesday passed a resolution to require Mayor Bob Filner to sign an operating agreement for the city’s Tourism Marketing District that the panel originally approved in November, despite his contentious plea for a two-day delay.

Filner has refused to sign the deal, which would release administrative funds to the agency that takes a 2 percent surcharge on hotel room rates, and uses the proceeds to promote San Diego as a vacation destination.

Last week, a judge ruled that Filner was not required to sign the document because the council only “authorized” his signature. The resolution passed today requires him to sign the contract.

While the judge didn’t make it part of his order, he did say in Friday’s hearing that Filner would have to sign the agreement if directed to by council members.

Filner told the council members that he came close to reaching a deal on a revised operating agreement with district officials in the last couple of days and asked them to wait two days before taking up the issue.

At a news conference after the council decision, Filner said he and district officials had resolved 90 percent of the issues and was confident he could complete a deal if given more time.

Filner said the remaining hang-ups were over how to publicly report the salaries of tourism officials, how to protect the city from adverse rulings from separate lawsuits over how the agencies are funded, and wording over the spending of $6 million to organize a year-long celebration of Balboa Park’s centennial.

However, the resolution that was passed will cause nothing but delays, Filner said.

“As you know, I can veto the resolution,” Filner told the council members. “As you know, I think it’s illegal. As I’ve said, I think it’s a bad deal for taxpayers. I’ve tried to make it better; I think we’re this close.

“You can override the veto,” Filner said. “I can refuse to sign it. We can go back to court. The court will make a decision, and I can appeal that decision. As the city attorney pointed out, right in the contract is the ability to hold up the whole expenditure of funds as long as there is litigation.”

Filner said the delay could “go on and on” for a year or more.

Filner also told the council members that they should recuse themselves, because they all received campaign donations from district board members. City Attorney Jan Goldsmith and council President Todd Gloria both received thousands of dollars from the tourism officials, Filner said.

“Why are they giving this money? So they can get this kind of backroom shady deal approved,” Filner said.

Goldsmith told the council members that they were covered by a legal exemption.

Filner said it was a sad day for San Diego that the dispute has polarized the city, and that everyone involved should apologize to residents. He also criticized Gloria for bringing the resolution forward.

“This was an attack, I think, on me rather than an attempt to come to a solution,” Filner said. “It was very irresponsible, frankly, Mr. Gloria, for you to have this on the agenda today. We could have brought this any time.”

Before the vote, Gloria said he would schedule a special meeting to offer amendments to the operating agreement, should Filner and the district negotiate a settlement.

Filner spoke for 13 minutes, was confronted by a hotel industry representative, and spoke for several more minutes despite Gloria’s attempts to begin council discussion.

Councilman Scott Sherman said there was a lot of “political theater” involved in the dispute in a veiled rebuke of the mayor.

“It kind of reminds me of a term I coined a while back regarding politicians, it’s what I call the arsonist-firemen,” Sherman said.

“They come in and start a fire and then say, wait a minute, I’ll come put it out and be a hero. It’s a different way of thinking about things  and it’s usually political theater time to get on a camera.”

The council vote was 6-1, large enough to override a veto.

Councilwoman Marti Emerald, who agreed with the mayor that indemnification in the contract was not strong enough, cast the dissenting vote. Separate lawsuits have been filed over the way the TMD is funded.

According to the resolution, the mayor’s obligation to sign the agreement is a “ministerial duty” and “he has no discretion to refuse to sign said Operating Agreement, and has no authority to further negotiate said Operating Agreement.”

The district distributes funds to organizations that stage events that attract visitors. A $5.4 million campaign advertising San Diego as a vacation destination this summer has been put on hold.


  • Lisa

    Filner is like the annoying kid in the playground……if you don't play the game the way I want to play, then I am going to pick up my ball and go home!!

  • UnionMess

    What idiots voted that guy for mayor? Comes in and thinks he's God Almighty. City Council just demoted him to Judas.

  • steven greenwal

    firstly mr turzis salary from taxpayors scarce dollars is over 400,000 a year,, second a 40 year contract with no intervening modifications allowed ,, third the city must be better protected in case this is deemed a TAX and deemed illegal

  • Artimus Maximus

    Mayor Filner is taking the correct and proper approach in this matter. He is an outsider looking in and what he sees is the overly paid heads of this Tourism Marketing District getting public funding for supposedly advertising to promote the City of San Diego. All of you who are critical of Mayor Filner's decision to reshape or redirect this mightier than thou, self entitled, that's the way it has been, cronyistic, overpaid, agency need to do your research and then you could comment when well informed instead of bashing the Mayor for attempting to fix something that is and has been broken for a long time. Thumbs up to city councilwoman Marti Emerald in being the sole council person to side with the Mayor! And one more point before ending this opinion. Mayor Filner is also correct in asking the people that received campaign contributions from the Tourism Marketing District to recluse themselves from this matter. Smells like I scratch your back and you scratch mine to me! Go Mayor Filner!

    • SirVivor

      You are spot on! If "they all received campaign donations from district board members." then they are not working for the public's best on this issue. I have suspected that most city council members have been on the take for years.

  • Guest

    It is too bad it took a judge to have to point out what should be obvious; the mayor cannot have a legit voice in this matter if he is forced to sign.

  • Graham

    Right on Mayor Filner. Remember San Diego voted for a strong mayor. The council is beholding to those that give them money…or a possible job after they are no longer on the council! Therefore; they don't want the salary cap passed!

  • toddler constipation remedies natural

    Also know about Loss of Appetite, Anorexia Treatment.
    Although this remains untested in labs, the effect of fish oil on my toddler made her constipation vanish when
    we discovered at an in-store sampling that Nordic Naturals Strawberry Children’s DHA gels were a treat to her. This article is FREE to publish with the resource box.

  • bad credit fast cash loans

    We absolutely love your blog and find nearly all of
    your post’s to be exactly I’m looking for. can you
    offer guest writers to write content for you? I wouldn’t mind composing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write with regards to here. Again, awesome web site!

  • Victoria

    Hello I am Victoria, it’s my first occasion commenting anyplace. When I found this post I thought I would comment due to its peremptory material on the subject. Well done.


    We turned on the wireless connection on both and checked that they could connect to the internet and worked at a decent pace.
    And with good reason because sometimes running an app on the
    big screen is nothing short of magical. The
    version of Windows on my tablet pc is Windows XP and
    there is no difference between it and the PC that I don’t use anymore.

  • 0 on balance transfers credit cards

    3 maximum aperture, fixed lens mount, auto focus features, 2.

    You can use your jammer to prevent them from sending and getting communication by suggests of their cell phones.

    Waiting until the park is about to close is one way to get some privacy, as is visiting the park during Disneyland’s less busy times.

  • Mable

    Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you so much, However I am going through
    difficulties with your RSS. I don’t understand
    the reason why I cannot subscribe to it. Is there anyone else having identical RSS problems?

    Anyone who knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

  • small japanese garden landscape

    Flower seeds can be added to the mix as well and would work well with
    dwarf zinnias, marigold and bright pansies ‘ but what you
    add it up to you. The possibilities, many and various, obtaining astounding results,
    I have found that there are so many people with wonderful
    ideas, provided, to share on the internet. Though you may end up
    spending more money, remember that you are paying for the quality of the goods and service that you are receiving.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.