Man files excessive force claim against off-duty sheriff’s detective

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

SAN DIEGO -- A motorist alleged Tuesday that a sheriff's detective used excessive force against him during a “road rage'' encounter last May, resulting in a claim against the county of San Diego, the Sheriff's Department and the lawman.

Robert Branch, speaking to reporters while flanked by his attorney, alleged that Detective Paul Ward put him in a bar-arm chokehold after following his vehicle off westbound Interstate 8 at College Avenue on May 4 about 5 p.m.

“I became afraid,'' Branch said, when Ward allegedly began to choke him.

Sheriff's spokeswoman Jan Caldwell said she couldn't comment on the claim, which is a precursor to a lawsuit.

“This matter has been referred to the District Attorney's Office, so I am not able to provide any information. However, this matter is under a thorough and exhaustive review with our internal Critical Incident Review Board,'' Caldwell said.

Branch claims that Ward -- driving an unmarked Ford sedan -- pulled up behind him about nine miles after Branch tried to pass the detective's car in El Cajon.

Branch said Ward -- dressed in civilian clothes -- threatened to arrest him for reckless driving, flashed a badge and demanded his license and registration.

According to his claim, Branch was afraid for his safety because he wasn't sure Ward was a law enforcement officer.

Branch, 25, said he started recording the encounter on his phone and was “incredulous'' that Ward hadn't called law enforcement.

Branch said Ward told him: “You are being detained,'' then grabbed him in a chokehold, cutting off his air flow.

The claim alleges Ward continued to choke Branch for about five more minutes.

At one point, a 9mm handgun fell out of Ward's ankle holster and was picked up by a witness, who called 911 and told an operator that he would hold onto the gun until police arrived.

As police sirens neared, Ward released Branch from the chokehold, according to the claim.

No criminal charges have been filed, according to attorneys handling the case.

5 comments

  • Republicans are dictators

    funny how fox news and republicans are racist, homophobic, misogynists being left in the dust …even the pope hates you now.

  • Idiot Liberal

    Wait’ll a jury gets a hold of the loser filing these frivolous complaints. His criminal history is going to shock some.

    That’s what “they” do…

    STOP BREAKING THE LAW!!

  • 2 idiots

    Both these idiots were out of line! 1 for a sheriffs investigator to do traffic enforcement and 2 for this kid to drive in such a way to attract this attention. The bad part of it is we citizens pay for both of these idiots! This is exactly why unmarked cars and plain clothed cops should never do traffic enforcement. It leads to confusion by citizens expecting a uniform and a marked car. Whats worse, Badges can be bought off ebay or at your favorite party store. Why would anyone in their right mind just pull over without a second thought?

    • Yup, 2 idiots!

      Yeah! Like those emails you get about winning! Anyone can send them! Only a fool would pull over for a badge and an unmarked car!

Comments are closed.